Somen Tchoyi scored his first hat-trick in English football as the Baggies made a remarkable comeback at St. James' Park.
Albion were 3-0 behind after 47 minutes before Tchoyi scored in the 62nd, 71st and then 90th minute to equalise; but who caught your eye?
Scott Carson won the Everton accolade with 34.4% of the votes.
Click here to cast your vote.